Some Chinese cash coins

7 Beiträge • 108 Mal aufgerufen

Dieses Thema wurde im Forum Englisch veröffentlicht

Hello everyone,

I would like to get some help identifying those Chinese cash coins. I figured out some details already I believe but still would appreciate your help with the others and/or links to numista. Especially #4 is odd.
All coins are ~23-24mm.
From left to right:

1.) Emperor Kangxi, Hartill 22.090
2.) Boo-chiowan, probably Qianlong https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces1133.html
3.) Also Boo-chiowan, Emperor Kangxi. Same as coin #1?
4.) Could be Quinlong, boo Yuwam. Odd color, coin has weak magnetic reaction. Maybe a fake?
5.) ?

Thanks
MS2007



Can anyone help with #4 please?
The material seems odd and I'd like to know if I should add the coins to my collection or just trash it (if fake).

Thanks
I'm not an expert on Chinese cash coins but to the best of my knowledge the only other material besides copper/brass/bronze used to make these coins was iron which would be highly magnetic and wouldn't look anywhere as "clean" as that coin. The only material I can think of that could be used to make coins/fakes and would be slightly magnetic would be some grades of stainless steels and non-magnetic grades of stainless steels after being cold worked such as being pressed into a coin. Chinese cash coins were not made of these materials.
For your two coins Kangxi, you might pick some differences (square head tong)


The fourth coin might be nickel plated that would explain the weak magnetism.
The lettering is quite close to DH# 22.260

The fifth coin is from Jiaqing probably Boo Yuwan
Referee of south atlantic islands
Awesome. Thank you so much for your replies. I will look closer at the information you provided.

#4: It's interesting that I can't find anything about the material as it seems to be so odd. If it is a common fake you would think it has been described or discussed before.
Verweis : "Frenchlover"​The fourth coin might be nickel plated that would explain the weak magnetism.


​Yes, that makes sense.
Verweis : "MS2007"... ​#4: It's interesting that I can't find anything about the material as it seems to be so odd. If it is a common fake you would think it has been described or discussed before.
​I don't remember any discussion about that. Yet the grained aspect on reverse looks odds.
Referee of south atlantic islands

» Forumsregeln

Die verwendete Zeitzone ist UTC+2:00.
Die aktuelle Zeit ist 19:06.