A little background:
George Soley was a die sinker who worked for the US Mint. In 1875 he purchased the Mint's first steam press as scrap and he refurbished it so he could produce tokens. Along with the press, he also purchased collars from the Type 1 gold dollars (which were no longer being produced). Thus, these tokens can be readily identified as his work, because of the roughly 13mm size and the well crafted lord's prayer he placed on the reverse.
Here is the most common one along with the SC of US Tokens 1700-1900 listing:
Sadly, there are a huge number of other tokens he produced with the same reverse, but different obverses, which are not listed. E.g.:
Does anyone know of a source for additional information on these tokens?