According to this Norwegian catalogue, KM#286 has two varieties, a thick type weighing 11.69 g (1819-1820) and a thin type weighing 9.35 g (1824-1834). Is this weight difference alone enough to split into two pages? If not, how should we record the weight?
Former Numista referee for banknotes from Ireland, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and Saint Helena.
It's just one of those bad decisions made a long time ago by numista, of course the two types should be separated!
I think the problem was that there were no weights in SCWC so they were added as the same coin type in Numista. The weight was added later. Once they're split in Numista then we'll have the same KM# for two different coins for the same issuer/country.
It's just one of those bad decisions made a long time ago by numista, of course the two types should be separated!
I think the problem was that there were no weights in SCWC so they were added as the same coin type in Numista. The weight was added later. Once they're split in Numista then we'll have the same KM# for two different coins for the same issuer/country.
Yes, it's a shame about the KM# but, unless there's another catalogue we can also refer to, we'll have to put up with it.
Former Numista referee for banknotes from Ireland, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and Saint Helena.
I agree, these should be distinct and I know for sure some Norwegian catalogs recognize them as such as well. I will have to dig some deeper in regards to this coin, as it appears to be even more different types. First of all I'm gonna prioritize having the appropriate reference catalog recognized by Numista. This might take some time.
Sincerely,
Tor
Best regards,
Tor
Status geändert zu Gestartet(Jarcek, 8 Feb. 2024, 09:51)
